Private island for sale in popular Ontario vacation area
Published July 9, 2025 at 1:05 pm
If you have ever dreamed of escaping to your own private island, there is one for sale now in Ontario.
An over two-acre “iconic private retreat” is listed for sale in Muskoka Lakes, a short boat ride from Port Carling. Port Carling is about a two-and-a-half-hour drive north of Toronto.
Onaway Island features 1,320 feet of pristine shoreline, a boathouse and “classic Canadian lodge,” according to the listing from Chestnut Park Real Estate.

The main cottage sits above the boathouse.
The main four-bedroom cottage is a “work of art” with bark-stripped columns, exposed rafter tails and a hand-laid stone fireplace. There are lake views from every room and porch.

The living room features a hand-laid stone fireplace.
The three-slip boathouse includes a second-storey living space and extensive docking.
Outside, the island is yours to explore with scenic island trails and hidden coves. A bocce court is nestled on the western side of the island.
The island even has its own helipad.

The three-slip boathouse.
“…Onaway Island is more than a property, it’s a lifestyle of heritage, tranquility, and refined recreation,” the listing states. “Offered fully turnkey, this once-in-a-generation offering invites you to live Muskoka at its most memorable.”
This place is listed for $11,995,000.
Photos: Chestnut Park Real Estate